Astro Boy Episode Guide

Talk about all things Astro Boy!
User avatar
jeffbert
Minister of Science
Posts: 12549
Joined: 22 years ago

Postby jeffbert » 15 years ago

:blush: Oops; I looked for the copyright notice only in the place where it would be found in a regular book. :blush: Inside the front cover on one of the very 1st pages, is the spot where such things are printed in any book I can imagine. Yet, these booklets are so thin, that they put the notice elsewhere.

Now if this content was indeed published in an older book, whose copyright may have lapsed, as some members assume, and the same exact content is currently under copyright in these booklets, how must we deal with this?

If The Right Stuf owned the copyright to the older book, then I must assume that it has the right to reprint that content verbatim in a newer publication, with a copyright notice thereon. Although no date appears on the notice on the booklets, & ownership is that of Tezuka Prod., etc, we must conclude that such content is indeed under current copyright.

In regards to future posting of such content, I maintain that short quotes posted in the context of a discussion involving their content should be ok, as long as the publication data, ie., source, etc is cited with the quote itself.

Example:

blah, blah, etc, Fred Ladd's book says "[quoted text]" & name the book somewhere within the post, as I myself routinely do. Also, it would help to provide a link to a page that sells the book, such as Amazon, etc.

Now, should I edit those posts & remove the content?
Image

User avatar
AprilSeven
Silent Song
Posts: 3783
Joined: 15 years ago
Location: Orange County, NY

Postby AprilSeven » 15 years ago

Bummer, but at least folks got to read some of it -- it's like the whole story is a puzzle to put together -- and some factoids contradict others!

It appears the only way to get the content now is to purchase BOTH DVD sets --which is silly, because you're spending another $100 for the exact same episodes (save for a couple Japanese versions in each set). Why not sell the background material/Japanese eps as a separate package (for maybe $30)? I WOULD buy that along with a boxed set.

:astro: - YOOOO HOOOO!! Right Stuf people!!! Listen to AprilSeven! She's your friend!!
Image Sig artwork by Alittleacorn!

User avatar
jeffbert
Minister of Science
Posts: 12549
Joined: 22 years ago

Postby jeffbert » 15 years ago

Ok, I have checked the US Copyright http://www.copyright.gov/circs/circ1.pdf, & found that 120 years is the minimum duration of copyrights. I must remove the content.

"Fauna" wrote:[QUOTE=jeffbert;104095]BTW, I appreciate this stuff, but please hold off posting any new material, as this is copyrighted in the USA.


I appreciate your copyright respect, and I too follow these rules, but this book hasn't been in print for more than fifteen years.[/QUOTE]
While I appreciate the fact that the book is out of print, given that
  1. copyrights are valid for over 100 years; and
  2. this same material is currently available in the boxed sets
I strongly condemn the wholesale posting of material as has been done on the 1st page of this thread. Moreover, I as one who has web published my own copyrighted work, would be very displeased to have someone do likewise with my stuff. I think it should be ok for you to discuss what content is in the book, ie, a table of contents, compare it with what other books say, & to paraphrase or quote short blocks of text in the context of discussing the content. If it were my work that were quoted in this fashion, I would not be displeased; in fact, I might be happy to see that people actually read & value my work.

"AprilSeven" wrote:Bummer, but at least folks got to read some of it -- it's like the whole story is a puzzle to put together -- and some factoids contradict others!

It appears the only way to get the content now is to purchase BOTH DVD sets --which is silly, because you're spending another $100 for the exact same episodes (save for a couple Japanese versions in each set). Why not sell the background material/Japanese eps as a separate package (for maybe $30)? I WOULD buy that along with a boxed set.

:astro: - YOOOO HOOOO!! Right Stuf people!!! Listen to AprilSeven! She's your friend!!



With respect to the content on page 1, though it is only the most basic of information, and that similar content is printed in more than a few other books, such as Fred Ladd's ASTRO BOY AND ANIME COME TO AMERICA, Fred Schodt's ASTRO BOY ESSAYS, this is still copyrighted material.
Last edited by jeffbert on Mon Aug 16, 2010 7:40 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image

User avatar
AprilSeven
Silent Song
Posts: 3783
Joined: 15 years ago
Location: Orange County, NY

Postby AprilSeven » 15 years ago

It's okay Jeff -- I didn't know if what I popped up there would be acceptable, and have no problem if you want to pull the whole thread. I don't have time to edit down that info right now -- but anyone else is welcome to do so.

We've learned much more since this Episode Guide was published, anyway -- I do wonder if they still maintain that Astro was supposed to exist in NEW YORK in the American version?

Thanks for keepin' us legit!
Image Sig artwork by Alittleacorn!


Return to “Astro Boy Discussion”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 110 guests