"Tetsuwan Penguin" wrote:What software did you use to separate the foreground from the background? I've used the GIMP for this, and it works well when there is a good deal of contrast separating the images. Even so, there is usually a lot of cleanup required at the pixel level along the cut points.
I use the XP-version of WindowsPaint because I'm a lot more comfortable working along the outlines. Windows7-WP doesn't do it for me. I probably should use GIMP too, but as you said, you can't really avoid cleaning up some parts.
There was hardly any contrast in the images above, as they originally show Astro floating in space, so I first had to light the images up via gamma correction and set it back to normal when the cutting was finished.
For the transparent background I use a little free GIF-software called Animake.
I'm not sure which version of Astro I like the best. The 1980 anime had him with the smallest head to height ratio of about 1 to 3 giving him that "cute widdle astro boy" look. In the 1963 anime he was mostly drawn at a 1 to 3.8 ratio, and the 2003 version was close to that as well. However there were other modifications made to his appearance in 2003 that I think gave him the most endearing look of all.
Each Astro version is fine with me, maybe apart from certain drawing styles used in some 80's episodes, particularly in 'The Hijacked Airship' or 'The Snow Leopard'. Astro just needs the proper amount of cuteness, otherwise there's something missing.

)
Certainly his appearance in the 1963 Anime is the closest to the manga (though some of the last manga released in the 1980's, IE: darkhorse #23, reflected the 1980 series). In the 1980 series he is always drawn with four fingers and a thumb, in the 1963 anime it's mostly with 3 fingers, though you can catch frames drawn with 4, and even some with "mitten" hands. Tezuka more often used the mitten style for bare feet though.
When I first read 'Let's Draw Astro Boy' by Junji Kobayashi it was really interesting to learn about Astro's slight changes of appearance through the years. I also remember reading somewhere in the Dark Horse mangas that Mr. Tezuka himself sometimes wasn't aware whether he drew Astro's hands with 4 or just 3 fingers.
I've done a few more (from the same episode):
