Just think of it like James Bond.....I LOVE Sean Connery, Roger Moore & Peirce Brosnan As Bond, But they are individual movies in there own respect and each have aspects that the others don't. I still love them all.
Regarding Bond, I think that only Sean Connery had the physique needed to portray the guy. Brosnan is a great actor, & I enjoy his portayal of Bond, but he is just not as convincing as Connery. He is just not built heavily enough. Kind of like Kirk Douglas playing Oddysius. The book discribes him as having massive shoulders, and while Douglas is a noteworthy actor, his body just does not fit the bill. These guys are just too skinny to be convincing. If Arnold Schwarzennegger turned down the role of Hercules and they offered it to Jim Carry, nobody would take the film seriously. That contrast is an exaggeration, but I think it illustrates my point.
